Early on in the game, I realized that I would not be able to read everything I wanted for both the Newbery Award and the Printz Award, so I chose the Newbery. The books are shorter, for one thing, and I helped to run our library system’s Mock Newbery Club for five years before I became a selector, so I have more experience with that competition.
This is not to say that I haven’t read for the Printz, however. I am more likely to read a Young Adult (YA) book on my own anyway, so it is not a burden to do so. The Michael L. Printz Award is given to the best book written for teens in each calendar year, and if you’ve seen the Hunger Games movies, you’ll know that YA authors are doing some great work and seeing substantial commercial success. The Printz Award is looking for literary quality, rather than popularity, though. One big difference between the Printz and the Newbery is that the Printz can be awarded to any author, regardless of nationality.
I’ve categorized all of the following YA books that were published in 2013 into four groups, along with some short comments. Almost all of those that I read have been reviewed on this blog. If not, there was probably a reason.
Group One: The Series. First of all, here are the books that I liked (or sometimes loved) very much, but I feel that they are so dependent on their prequels and/or sequels that they cannot stand on their own:
Across a Star-Swept Sea, by Diana Peterfreund (Second in a fun series.)
The Bitter Kingdom, by Rae Carson (Third in a great trilogy.)
The Clockwork Princess, by Cassandra Clare (Third in a fabulous trilogy.)
The Dream Thieves, by Maggie Stiefvater (Maggie never disappoints. Second in a wonderful series. Complex characters.)
Etiquette & Espionage, by Gail Carriger (Fun series derived from her adult series “The Parasol Protectorate.”)
The Lord of Opium, by Nancy Farmer (So very literary. Wonderful, but dependent on House of the Scorpion.)
Quintana of Charyn, by Melina Marchetta (Third in THE trilogy. “The Lumatere Chronicles” is THE series for older teens and adults.)
Group Two: Not winners. Here is another list of titles that I just do not find literary enough for the award. Some of these are top contenders on other lists, but I feel that there are better titles this year. Although they are not my picks for an award, a few were very good reads. If you’d like more information about a title in this list that I did not review, let me know.
All Our Pretty Songs, by Sarah McCarry- So many drugs, and I can’t quite remember the plot.
Far Far Away, by Tom McNeal- I liked this, but not as much as many others did.
The Golden Day, by Ursula Dubosarsky- Characters too young; not enough character development.
The Kingdom of Little Wounds, by Susann Cokal- Absolutely not. This is an adult book—for adults with strong stomachs. What was Candlewick thinking? The characters are teens because they lived in a time when girls married at 13 and were happy to live to age 30.
More Than This, by Patrick Ness- Loads of fun, but derivative. Not as literary as others.
Rapture Practice, by Aaron Hartzler- Nicely done memoir. I just liked other things better.
Reality Boy, by A.S. King- A compelling story by an exceptional author, but not a favorite this year. I loved her Everybody Sees the Ants.
Sex & Violence, by Carrie Mesrobian. Great character development with a weak ending. Much better than you’re thinking.
The Sin-Eater’s Confession, by Ilsa J. Bick- A rugged read. I could not get over the author’s bigoted depiction of Christians.
The Summer Prince, by Alaya Dawn Johnson- Oh, so pretentious. Many experts disagree, but I did not like any of the characters. It reminded me of the values expressed in Somerset Maugham’s The Moon and Sixpence: artists are exempt from “middle-class morality.”
Group Three: I ran out of time. Books that are on many top Printz prediction lists that I did not read, although I would like to, are:
Charm & Strange, by Stephanie Kuehn
The Coldest Girl in Coldtown, by Holly Black
Midwinterblood, by Marcus Sedgwick [Update! Please see review on January 26, 2014]
Picture Me Gone, by Meg Rosoff
Rose Under Fire, by Elizabeth Wein (Loved the first one.)
Winger, by Andrew Smith
I actually had some of these on my nighttable, but I just ran out of time.
Group Four: The winners! That leaves me with this list of six favorites for the year, two by one author!
All the Truth That’s in Me, by Julie Berry- Tense, gritty. Great main character in a unique story.
Boxers & Saints, by Gene Luen Yang- This is actually a pair of graphic novels based on the Boxer Rebellion in China, and it works incredibly well! Complex and surprising. Will the committee consider it one work?
Eleanor & Park, by Rainbow Rowell- Ripped my heart out. My emotions were completely engaged. Tremendous character development. This is my top pick of the year.
Fangirl, by Rainbow Rowell- A three-layer novel with great characters. Fun, engaging; engrossing story.
The Midnight Dress, by Karen Foxlee- Lush writing, beautiful setting, and a strong main character.
Out of the Easy, by Ruta Sepetys- A true coming-of-age story with an exceptional setting.
In summary, my favorite three, in order, are probably:
1) Eleanor & Park
2) The Midnight Dress
All of these favorites are great reads for adults and teens, and these authors are among the best anywhere. Go check them out!
We’re making a party out of the ALA Children’s Media Awards at our library. Tune into the webcast here by 8:00 on Monday morning, January 27th. No matter which titles garner the medals, all the readers win!
Disclaimer: All opinions expressed are completely my own and do not reflect those of my employer, several friends, or the professional medal-watch bloggers. But we have fun.